High-definition TVs display fantastic images that make movies and TV
shows come alive like never before. But playing video games on an HDTV can be
rather tricky, especially if they require precise
timing, like Rock Band or the latest version of Tiger Woods PGA TOUR®. I'm
talking about "gaming lag" — a very small but noticeable delay in the
amount time it takes an HDTV to display images from a video game console. And a
delay in how long it takes for your actions on the controller to register on
the TV screen.
So what is it?
Every HDTV has a
fixed, or "native," resolution, such as 1080p or 720p. An HDTV must convert any incoming
signal, no matter what the source, to its native resolution. Unfortunately for
us gamers, this conversion takes time; time that can mean a delay of up to a
few frames of video or more. So with many HDTVs, where you see that colored
note on Rock Band isn't where it "really" is; it's actually off by a
few frames due to the amount of time it takes for the TV to convert the signal
to its native resolution.
As you might guess, lag time will be the longest when the resolution of your console doesn't match the
resolution of your HDTV. Playing a standard-definition console like the Wii™ or
PS2 on a 1080p TV will result in the greatest lag, while a high-def console
like the Xbox 360™ or PS3 running on this same TV may not lag at all.
Gaming lag also stems from the fact that most HDTVs are designed to display
eye-catching images with extraordinary detail, depth, and color accuracy. Many
of them include extra video processing to achieve this goal. However, these TVs
are built for beauty, and not speed. This extra video processing also takes
time, which can make the lag even worse.
Gaming lag — first hand
Since getting an HDTV a few months ago, I've had some first-hand experience with
gaming lag. I noticed it
the first time I fired up Guitar Hero™ II (PS2 version) on my new HDTV. I had
heard about gaming lag before, but never had the chance to experience it personally. I missed notes left and
right, including ones that I knew I hit. Guitar Hero II includes a utility that calculates your HDTV's lag, so I
ran it to see what it would tell me. Sure enough, it said I had a lag of
approximately 100ms. That may not sound like much, but that's 1/10 of a second
— a big deal when you're playing a game that requires precise timing.
Now, I don't mean to alarm
any gamers who are shopping for an HDTV. Lag may be an issue for games that
require precise timing like music and sports games, but not for other types of
games like turn-based strategy ones. While I enjoy the occasional round of
Guitar Hero, my main gaming passion is Japanese RPGs, particularly the
old-school turn-based kind. Lag was the furthest thing from my mind during my
recent playthrough of Persona 3 FES.
Game Mode
Thankfully, many HDTV
manufacturers, such as Sony, Samsung, and Toshiba (their 52" REGZA® LCD HDTV's pictured above), include a "Game Mode" to eliminate or minimize gaming lag. Game Mode speeds up image
processing time, and often turns off any extra video processing designed to
make movies and TV shows look their best. My TV has such a mode, and it lowered
the amount of lag in Guitar Hero II from 100ms to 24ms. That's a definite
improvement, and I'm now playing like I was on my old, lag-free CRT set.
Theoretically, game mode may lead to a small drop in image quality, but I sure
haven't noticed it. So if you're looking for an HDTV and you plan on rocking out with Rock Band or challenging Tiger Woods to 18 holes at Sawgrass, make sure you pick out a set with a Game Mode.
Posted
Thu, Sep 25 2008 8:35 AM
by
LorenB