Have you tried calling CrutchField with this request? The customer service rep will be more able to help you than this forum can. Their phone number is 1-800-955-9091.
However, I am interested [in all seriousness about your post]: Can you explain what resources are not renewable with a paper catalog? Is it the ink or staples?
Current Gear: Sammy DLP Sony DVD [pre-HDMI] Sony STR-DE 995 Sony speakers
First let me say that I am sorry that you ran into problems in canceling the catalog. I am currently trying to get info on what happened, and I will post back once I have that info.
In the meantime you can contact our catalog team by phone at 1-800-955-9009 — 8am-midnight Eastern Time to cancel. If you would prefer you can also Private Message me with your name, address and zip code and I will be happy to take care of this for you.
You can always unsubscribe from the Crutchfield catalog by calling us at 1-800-955-9009 or e-mailing us at catalog@crutchfield.com.
Right now we are evaluating CatalogChoice as a service to our customers. On the plus side, it is very convenient. On the down side, there are privacy concerns (I could unsubscribe you and you could unsubscribe me). Also, a significant portion of the companies listed on the site are not actually participants.
There is also a similar service which the bulk of the industry (including Crutchfield) already uses: http://www.dmachoice.org/. This allows you to remove your name from all catalogs at once (something CatalogChoice does not do) and also has information on telemarketing and email lists.
We will continue to monitor all services that could benefit our customers. In the meantime, please contact us directly if you’d like to be removed from our mailing list. It’s the best way to make sure that your request is processed quickly and accurately.